I very much enjoyed this dark fable of the subtle seductiveness of evil, and the power of redemption.
Ray Milland is absolutely superb in his role as Nick Beal, a supernaturally gifted interloper in human affairs. In fact, I've never seen him better; his performance here is even more potent, believable, affecting, and nuanced than it was in The Lost Weekend (1945), for which he won an academy award. He's certainly at the top of his game in this film.
Thomas Mitchell, the beloved Uncle Billy of It's A Wonderful Life (1946), is quite strong, too, as the ethical district attorney who, in the midst of his good intentions, is led down a slippery path of moral relativity.
Geraldine Wall, who we don't seem to hear enough about in film reviews and essays, plays Mitchell's wife, and she's extremely good as well. She has stalwart strength, wisdom, and a highly perceptive insight that, quite frankly, the character of her husband seems to lack.
Film noir regulars George Macready and Fred Clark provide solid support to the proceedings. They add texture and color to the drama.
But I must say that Audrey Totter is simply stunning in her performance as a thoroughly down on her luck "lady of the streets". Her otherworldly transformation from a truly pitiful wreck of a woman, into a glamorous and chillingly manipulative agent of sinister forces, has to be seen to be believed. It's an incredible transition in both style and substance, and it adds immeasurably to the film's mystique and its quiet power. Totter's performance is undeniably one of the dramatic cornerstones of this movie.
As for the plot, and the narrative, it's hard to know where to begin. This film is a theological exploration, but it is very definitely also a suspense thriller. And it is also a morality play, but it is a subtly toned character study as well.
And.... this movie is creepy. Very, very creepy. As in, for instance, the fact that Ray Milland's character "can't stand to be touched". Or that Milland very casually kills one of his underlings on the wharf; if he is, indeed, "Lucifer", is he allowed to kill human beings on a whim? That's a theological quandary, if you ask me. And Audrey Totter's character is ostensibly "evil" and chilling, but she is also so thoroughly human that it's obvious she has potent qualities of grace and goodness running beneath the surface.
Milland himself is a major factor in this creepiness. He is charming, alluring, and thoroughly persuasive in his methods. But, each and every moment, there is something "not quite right" about this gentleman. He's slightly "off". Even in all of his charisma and facile maneuvering, he is still disturbingly off-center and frighteningly sinister.
This has to be a once in a lifetime peak performance on Milland's part.
And back to the plot -- it's a relatively simple one: Should you perform -- or succumb to -- a series of little evils in order to vanquish a greater evil? Or should you look the other way at ethical breaches and slippery morality, in order to do a "good deed"? Even though the plot is straightforward, it is still powerful and gripping. And you can't help but feel for Thomas Mitchell's character as he passionately tries to defeat criminal kingpins, while at the same time becoming steadily more corrupt himself.
All told, i thought this was a marvelous movie. Some viewers may object to the "happy ending", which is largely facilitated by George Macready and Geraldine Wall's characters. Personally, I thought the ending worked quite well, but it may not be very fashionable, in the 21st century, for evil to be defeated so soundly.
I enjoyed every minute of this film. I can easily see myself watching it again and again. It's a classic of it's genre. And it does have some clear film noir aspects, especially in its cinematography and characterizations.
I hope you will enjoy this supernatural tour de force as much as I did.
Frequently bought together
- +
- +
Total Price:
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Choose items to buy together.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Customer reviews
Top reviews from other countries
William de Lay
Darkly Fascinating Exploration Of Good And Evil, With Some Clever Twists
Reviewed in the United States on 26 August 2021Verified Purchase
John Fowler
BLU-RAY REVIEW
Reviewed in the United States on 17 July 2021Verified Purchase
John Fowler
Reviewed in the United States on 17 July 2021
Unless you think selling your soul to the devil is a crime.
Thomas Mitchell is a politician who sells his soul to the devil, played by Ray Milland.
The devil uses Audrey Totter as the femme fatale to lure his victim.
TCM Noir Alley host Eddie Muller, in the audio commentary, describes this as “Faust-noir”, based on the Faust legend, best remembered for Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s 1832 dramatization.
Come to think of it, Ray Milland does murder a guy, but he was a minor character and easily overlooked.
The Hollywood Production Code required that murderers be punished by the end of the film, but apparently this didn’t apply to Satan.
Professional courtesy.
Audrey Totter was a film noir icon, and her presence in the cast, plus the stark black and white cinematography, are the film’s principal claims to film noir status.
Kino-Lorber supplies English subtitles + a selection of Ray Milland movie trailers + an audio commentary by Eddie Muller.
Eddie Muller used to do a lot of audio commentaries for DVDs, but this is his first one in four years, since he took over hosting duties for TCM’s Noir Alley.
I liked this film, and I liked it a lot more after listening to his commentary (Ray Milland really is doing an Evil Cary Grant impersonation).
But I still don’t think it’s film noir.
This was not the first time Hollywood had dramatized the Faust legend, but prior to this, the devil was usually treated for laughs (it was different in European cinema).
Six years earlier, the Faust legend was presented as a musical comedy with an all-Black cast in ‘Cabin in the Sky’ (MGM 1943), which is also highly recommended.
Left to Right in each photo:
Victim: Eddie “Rochester” Anderson in ‘Cabin in the Sky’ / Thomas Mitchell: in ‘Alias Nick Beal’
Femme-Fatale: Lena Horne in ‘Cabin in the Sky’ / Audrey Totter in ‘Alias Nick Beal’
Devil: Rex Ingram in ‘Cabin in the Sky’ / Ray Milland in ‘Alias Nick Beal’
Images in this review
bonnie dean
Good movie
Reviewed in the United States on 19 September 2021Verified Purchase
Alyce
Good but sound is distorted.
Reviewed in the United States on 13 August 2021Verified Purchase
Mark Mcgee
DECENT PICTURE QUALITY
Reviewed in the United States on 21 July 2021Verified Purchase
