Amazon.com.au:Customer reviews: A Dark Matter (The Skelfs Book 1)
Skip to main content
.com.au
Hello Select your address
All
Select the department you want to search in
Hello, Sign in
Account & Lists
Returns & Orders
Cart
All
Best Sellers Customer Service Prime Today's Deals Fashion Music New Releases Books Kindle Books Electronics Home Gift Cards Toys & Games Computers Audible Video Games Beauty Sports, Fitness & Outdoors Home Improvement Health & Personal Care Gift Ideas Pet Supplies Automotive Coupons Subscribe and save Sell
PrimeVideo

  • A Dark Matter (The Skelfs Book 1)
  • ›
  • Customer reviews

Customer reviews

4.1 out of 5 stars
4.1 out of 5
644 global ratings
5 star
40%
4 star
36%
3 star
17%
2 star
4%
1 star
3%
A Dark Matter (The Skelfs Book 1)

A Dark Matter (The Skelfs Book 1)

byDoug Johnstone
Write a review
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
See All Buying Options

Search
Sort by
Top reviews
Filter by
All reviewers
All stars
Text, image, video
644 global ratings | 60 global reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From Australia

Morningdew
5.0 out of 5 stars A really good read.
Reviewed in Australia on 2 August 2020
Verified Purchase
I loved this book. It was well written and a good story. I loved the setting - now in Australia, I grew up near the Braid Burn, and I well remember the daily walk down the Middle Meadow Walk to school in George Square. The author made the Edinburgh scene very vivid, his clear descriptions of the places worked cleverly into the writing. I also loved the way his personal knowledge of physics and and music added depth to the book. It made the character of Hannah, a physics student, more convincing when it could be shown that her studies affected the way she saw the world. The opening I'm not quite sure about, however. I think it may prevent some readers from continuing.
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Holly B.
1.0 out of 5 stars Depressing and stupid
Reviewed in Australia on 21 January 2022
Verified Purchase
So disappointed. Sounded like a great premise but really sorry I spent my time reading this. Preposterous ending and the characters all behaved weirdly. I don't usually leave negative reviews but this was just awful.
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Thought provoking - great storyline
Reviewed in Australia on 16 April 2021
Verified Purchase
Excellent, thought provoking
Very hard to put down
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Monica Mac
TOP 100 REVIEWER
4.0 out of 5 stars A good start for a new series but needs a bit of tweaking.
Reviewed in Australia on 5 July 2020
I have to admit, I was a little bit conflicted about this book.

This was the story about 3 generations of strong Skelf women. Dorothy, the matriarch who discovers that her recently deceased husband was keeping secrets from her; Jenny the daughter who is forced to return home to help run the family funeral business and finds herself in all sorts of hot water on several fronts and Hannah, who is a physics nerd and whose best friend goes missing. Naturally, Jenny and Hannah investigate this by themselves because, as you do, the Skelfs also have a private investigation business on the side.

I found this story a little confusing at the beginning, and not with as much depth as I would have liked. It built up to being quite intense towards the end and the thriller aspect of it came out. Overall, I thought it was a good book but I would have liked to have got a better sense about Dorothy and her drumming and Hannah with her studies. Hopefully, all will be revealed in future books!

3.5 rounded up to 4.
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


From other countries

sarah bourne
2.0 out of 5 stars I tried to love this book!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 30 November 2019
Verified Purchase
I really tried to love this book. It has an interesting premise, an unusual setting (an undertaker's), and I like strong female characters. The trouble with this book was that I found the book quite slow and repetitive, the author wanting us to know how much he knows about particle physics, music, bodies, etc, and these passages took me out of the story. I also found the characters to be unbelievable - I know it's fiction, but as a reader I need to be taken along on their journey and understand why they act as they do, and I just didn't feel that in this book. Sorry.
15 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Paris
TOP 1000 REVIEWER
5.0 out of 5 stars A tremendous find
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 6 February 2020
Verified Purchase
I found this via a reviewin The Guardian and saw it was praised by Val McDermid and Ian Rankin, so it had big shoes to fill. It did so and then some; I thoroughly enjoyed this slightly quirky take on crime/investigation and I am delighted to find that Doug Johnstone has a back catalogue for me to work through, can only hope his earlier books are of the same standard.
The characters were so well drawn, different threads worked in so that they appeared seamless. The standard of writing was excellent, as a pet hate for me is clunky dialogue, together with any need to explain events. I think good writing is that where the plot flows without such a need and this was very much of that quality. I found it hard to put this book down and I love finding this in any novel. Although I enjoyed this as a stand alone book, I do hope it is the start of a series; these characters are too good to be left here!
I read a little about the author and discovered such an interesting background, physics and music; who knew ? Loved how it came together here. Hope this does not sound worthy, but not all men writing about women can do as good a job as DJ. Their characters rang true and I agree with the lovely policeman who said the Skelf women were strong; more power to their elbows!
11 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Read and Reviewed
TOP 1000 REVIEWER
3.0 out of 5 stars Muted execution of an oiginal set-up with three generations of one family tackling death & crime.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 28 February 2020
Verified Purchase
A Dark Matter introduces the Skelf family and three generations of women whose surname is synonymous with death in the city of Edinburgh. With the family home having doubled as a funeral parlour for the last century and a private investigators for the last decade, wife, daughter and granddaughter are laying patriarch, Jim, to rest in a contrary cremation he explicitly requested. But business must go on even with the man at the helm gone, with seventy-year-old widow, Dorothy, divorced adult daughter, Jenny, and twenty-year-old physics student and granddaughter, Hannah, forced to compartmentalise their own grief. A tough ask when there is literally no escape from mortality as they enable other families to process their own personal grief and nigh on impossible when dark secrets from the past emerge and threaten everything they hold dear.

As Californian native and compassionate yoga loving widow, Dorothy, takes charge of the funeral side of the business and discovers mysterious monthly payments for the last decade she is devastated to realise that the man she shared everything with lied to her. Forced to question her marriage to Jim and determined to get to the bottom of his duplicity, tenacious Dorothy vows to discover the truth. As bitter and broke middle-aged divorcée, Jenny, comes to terms with being unemployed and moving back home the relatively straightforward sounding adultery case she picks up soon becomes far more complex than simply sitting in the van and tailing her target. Meanwhile overearnest student, Hannah, is hit by a fresh tragedy as her best friend from university, Mel, vanishes. Mired in their own grief and without any option but to go on, all three women are about to be tested to their limit as three investigations are set in motion, alongside a backdrop of funeral proceedings.

The premise and the whole set-up of A Dark Matter is something to savour and my disappointment was that the novel proved to be far less exciting than it promised, with sleuthing more akin to the blundering of cosy crime novels. Dorothy’s detective friend, Thomas Olsson, is also on hand to conveniently run DNA tests and interview people willy-nilly making much of what unfolds highly improbable. In this sense apart from some well-placed gallows humour (from Jenny especially) and Johnstone’s realistic attitude to the business of death, the investigations of all three women owe more to a cheesy crime caper. It is only thanks to the plot being so busy that the novel holds the attention as it moves sequentially though each of the trio of women’s individual perspectives and nudges each of their cases onwards ahead of a lively denouement.

The narrative throughout leans heavily towards the politically correct with middle-aged white men getting a bad press for starters. Whilst this does not detract from the novel it feels unnecessarily heavy-handed, likewise the constant referencing back to the physics of matter obviously intended to illustrate that we are bit part players in the wider scheme of things. Dorothy was the strongest of the three protagonists to my mind and a character that I empathised with but dissatisfied Jenny and dull Hannah failed to make a significant impression on me.

Whilst I hope to read more of the Skelf women’s juggling death and private investigation whilst also managing their own life dramas, I am hoping that future outings will be both darker and their unconventional methods of detection will become more credible! With all three generations learning something about themselves in the aftermath of Jim’s death the next instalment has the potential to build on solid series opener and expand on their characterisation.
6 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Jacob Collins
TOP 1000 REVIEWER
5.0 out of 5 stars Original and fantastic writing!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 28 January 2020
Verified Purchase
Doug Johnstone is fast becoming one of my favourite writers. His previous book, Breakers, was one of my top reads of 2019 and he has pulled it off again with A Dark Matter.

I think this book has one of the most original openings I’ve read in a long while. I did have to go over the first two sentences a couple of times as it dawned on me what was happening. Doug Johnstone pulls you into his story with a somewhat disturbing opening as a corpse is being fried. This opening scene grabbed my attention, and I wanted to know what the hell was going on here. But the opening scene isn’t quite as sinister as you might think; there are a lot more sinister scenes to come.

In Doug’s last book, I loved the raw, authentic voice he gave to his characters. In this book, we meet a family who own a funeral home, the Skelfs, which also operates as a private detective agency. I really liked this idea. It did give the book a Miss Marple and an Inspector Poirot kind of feeling.

Hannah, who is the granddaughter of Dorothy, who now solely owns the business after the death of her husband, Jim, is distraught when her friend Mel disappears. She begins investigating Mel’s disappearance on her own and takes matters into her own hands when it appears that the police show little interest. Hannah is tough and is absolutely determined to find out what has happened to her Mel. But meanwhile, another mystery is taking up her mother’s time. Hannah’s mother, Jenny, has found out that the business is still paying money to the wife of a former employee who also strangely disappeared. She can’t understand why the business is still paying this money and begins to suspect that her father, Jim, may have had a hand in his disappearance. Did he reach an agreement with his former employee’s wife to keep her silent on the matter?

I did think that A Dark Matter didn’t have the same, quite high level of tension as Breakers did, but I did become utterly immersed in the story. It is quite a different book, and it does stand out, it’s hard to place it into just one genre. Doug really captures Hannah’s anger as she searches for answers behind Mel’s disappearance, and also in Jenny’s despair, as she tries to work out what has been going on behind her back within the business. Doug Johnstone has a real talent for giving his characters strong, emotional depth which really brings them to life and makes them feel like real people.

You will be rooting for the characters to reach the answers that they are desperately craving. A Dark Matter is a totally original novel that will have you begging for the next chapter in the series. Fantastic writing!
4 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Mrs Graham
5.0 out of 5 stars Perfection!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 16 February 2021
Verified Purchase
This book is so good its my first 5 star rating of the year! It follows the story of the Skelf family who run a funeral parlour with a private investigation business on the side in Edinburgh. When the man of the house Jim dies he leaves his wife, daughter and granddaughter in a world of secrets and lies as they wrestle with their own grief and the murky business they've now been left to manage.
The book is extremely well written and the plot is excellent. All the characters are relatable and I felt myself genuinely loving or raging at people in the story as I was so immersed in it. I heard about the book in a list of Scottish fiction by The Scottish Book Trust and I'm so glad I decided to pick it up. I've already started the second book The Big Chill and I'll be preordering the third book when its available as its out in August!!
Pick it up you won't regret it :)
Customer image
Mrs Graham
5.0 out of 5 stars Perfection!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 16 February 2021
This book is so good its my first 5 star rating of the year! It follows the story of the Skelf family who run a funeral parlour with a private investigation business on the side in Edinburgh. When the man of the house Jim dies he leaves his wife, daughter and granddaughter in a world of secrets and lies as they wrestle with their own grief and the murky business they've now been left to manage.
The book is extremely well written and the plot is excellent. All the characters are relatable and I felt myself genuinely loving or raging at people in the story as I was so immersed in it. I heard about the book in a list of Scottish fiction by The Scottish Book Trust and I'm so glad I decided to pick it up. I've already started the second book The Big Chill and I'll be preordering the third book when its available as its out in August!!
Pick it up you won't regret it :)
Images in this review
Customer image
Customer image
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Spicewalker
TOP 500 REVIEWER
5.0 out of 5 stars Science, murder and funeral parlours.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 5 January 2020
Verified Purchase
A Dark Matter is the first book in the Skelfs series and what a start it is. This book is a fabulous blend of family, science, and mystery . A story which is surrounded by death, but for none of the typical reasons - although there is a murder to solve. But when the people looking into the crime manage both a Private Investigation firm AND a funeral home, you know that things are going to get interesting. Quite the unconventional mix wouldn't you say?

Now this has to be possibly one of the most unusual openings to a novel I have read in many a year. We are introduced to the Skelf women, three generations of them in fact, as they attend the funeral of Patriarch of the family, Jim. Nothing unusual in that you might think. And you'd be right ... apart from the circumstances of the, er, style of the funeral. I'll let you read to see what I mean but part of me read it thinking 'now that is the way to go.'. Also yuk.

The core of the story follows two threads. One is a secret that matriarch, Dorothy, discovers about Jim in the weeks after his death. This is something she is determined to get to the bottom of, seeking the help of her friend and former police officer, Thomas. This is an interesting side story and one which kept me hooked, wondering about what might be going on, suspecting as Dorothy did, that it was one answer and being completely floored by the opposite.

Then there is the secondary story, one that surrounds the disappearance of one of Jenny's roommates this is the story that really dominates, drives the tension and mystery and brings us right into the heart of the Skelf family and the sideline that they have as part time private investigators. There are a wealth of suspects, a myriad of secrets and a whole lot of science. I think I learned more from this book than I ever did attending school ...

I loved the characters of the Skelf women - Dorothy, Hannah and Jenny. They are all strong in their own way, although Hannah is perhaps the weakest of the three, reeling from a failed marriage and the loss of her job , her home and her father, the last three in quick succession. She takes over the PI business, slowly finding herself and her stride and as much as I'd often like to shake her and wake her up, I did admire her in a way too. Jenny is young, confident, tenacious and a complete science geek, the author using all his own knowledge and experience to create a character who makes nerdism look good. And then there is Dorothy, the strongest of the lot. I really liked her and her willingness to confront the truth no matter the cost to her.

I really enjoyed this story, becoming completely immersed in it from the off. Yes there is a lot of technical information imparted from a science point of view, but this fascinated me. I also loved the way in which the action was blended with the everyday of the funeral parlour and intrigued as to how mixing this with a PI business would work but, perhaps bizarrely, it did. The author has done his research, not overwhelming the reader with the facts, but giving just enough to bring authenticity to the piece.

This is not a fast past novel. It is not a ramped up police investigation all high tech tools and DNA sampling. It is a young woman trying to find her friend, a mother trying to hunt down potentially unfaithful spouses and a Grandmother seeking the truth. But it is still gripping, still full of thrills. Still full of the powerful, emotive and visually driven narrative that Doug Johnstone is known for. He sets the scene perfectly, be it the funeral home, the University or just the city itself, and you do not need to know the area to feel as though you are there.

Towards the end, when the full truth begins to emerge, the tension starts to build and there are some really edge of the seats moments, followed by a more serene and reflective final chapter that just left me wanting more. And I mean - imagine the business opportunities here. Have you been murdered? No problem. We'll work out who did it and even give you a really good price on your coffin in a January sale murder package special ... Come on - tell me that does not have legs.
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
  • ←Previous
  • Next page→
Need customer service? Click here
‹ See all details for A Dark Matter (The Skelfs Book 1)

Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations
›
View or edit your browsing history
After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in.

Back to top
Get to Know Us
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Corporate Information
  • Press Releases
  • Amazon Science
Make Money with Us
  • Independently Publish with Us
  • Sell on Amazon
  • Drive with Amazon Flex
  • Advertise Your Products
  • Associates Program
  • Host an Amazon Hub
Let Us Help You
  • COVID-19 and Amazon
  • Your Account
  • Your Orders
  • Delivery Rates & Policies
  • Returns & Replacements
  • Manage Your Content and Devices
  • Help
  • Brazil
  • Canada
  • China
  • France
  • Germany
  • India
  • Italy
  • Japan
  • Mexico
  • Netherlands
  • Poland
  • Singapore
  • Spain
  • Turkey
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
And don't forget:
  • Amazon Advertising
  • Amazon Web Services
  • Goodreads
  • Shopbop
  • Conditions of Use & Sale
  • Privacy Notice
  • Interest-Based Ads Notice
© 1996-2022, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates